Earth-like planets in dead star ‘cosmic graveyards’ get stranger
New findings show that Earth-size planets may be even less likely to survive the violent conditions at the end of some stars’ lives than previously believed. This means that the first exoplanet discovered outside the solar system 30 years ago may be far weirder than we realized.
Discovered in 1992 by astronomers Alex Wolszczan and Dale Frail, the planet PSR B1257+12B has an Earth-like mass and orbits an exotic type of dead star called a pulsar. The discovery was followed by the revelation that the planet is accompanied by at least two other worlds. These other planets orbiting the pulsar PSR B1257+12 are also of similar sizes to the rocky worlds of the solar system.
However, the largest study of pulsars and their planets ever conducted has shown that these dead stars rarely possess Earth-like companions. That makes this system, which NASA describes (opens in new tab) as a “graveyard” following the supernova that created PSR B1257+1, a rarity.
And conditions in the system, located 2,300 light-years away from Earth, aren’t getting any more hospitable. The pulsar at its heart spins every 6.22 milliseconds, or about 161 times a second, blasting its planets with an intense beam of deadly radiation that can be detected from Earth.
It’s little wonder the pulsar has picked up the nickname “Lich” after a powerful and evil undead creature of the same name in fantasy.
A survey of 800 pulsars over the past 50 years carried out by researchers at Britain’s Jodrell Bank Observatory has revealed that only 0.5% of pulsars host planets with masses similar to Earth. The researchers’ results were published (opens in new tab) in the Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society.
The finding deepens the mystery of how planets can survive around pulsars which, like all neutron stars, form when massive stars reach the end of nuclear fusion and the outward pressure that supports them against gravitational collapse ceases.
The resultant collapse creates a massive supernova explosion, often powerful enough to outshine every star in the galaxy that hosts them. Ultimately this leaves behind a neutron star with a mass similar to that of the sun within a radius similar to that of a city on Earth. Neutron stars consist of the densest known matter in the universe: just a teaspoon of this matter would weigh 8 trillion pounds (3.6 trillion kilograms).
“[Pulsars] produce signals which sweep the Earth every time they rotate, similarly to a cosmic lighthouse,” University of Manchester Ph.D. student Iuliana-Camelia Nițu said in a statement (opens in new tab). “These signals can then be picked up by radio telescopes and turned into a lot of amazing science.”
While many pulsars have been found to host exotic worlds unlike anything found in the solar system, the violent conditions that surround the births of pulsars and their continued existence seem to make the formation of Earth-like planets around them unlikely.
Related: The 10 most Earth-like exoplanets
An illustration of a pulsar blasting an Earth-like world with deadly radiation. (Image credit: NASA, JPL-Caltech and R. Hurt)
Nițu was part of a team of astronomers from the University of Manchester that performed the largest search of planets around pulsars to date, focusing on planets with masses up to 100 times that of the Earth, and orbital time periods between 20 days and 17 years.
They made ten potential detections of such worlds, with the system most likely to host exoplanets of this nature being PSR J2007+3120. The team believes that this pulsar, located 17,000 light-years from Earth, could host two planets with masses a few times that of Earth and with orbital periods of between 1.9 and around 3.6 years respectively.
The astronomers didn’t find enough information to say that planets around pulsars share similar masses and orbital periods, but they do appear to have something else in common: The exoplanets around the pulsars investigated appear to have highly elliptical orbits, unlike the near-circular orbits of planets in the solar system.
This could indicate that however planets around pulsars form, these processes differ from the mechanism that led to the formation of planets in the solar system.
“Pulsars are incredibly interesting and exotic objects. Exactly 30 years ago, the first extrasolar planets were discovered around a pulsar, but we are yet to understand how these planets can form and survive in such extreme conditions,” Nițu said in a statement (opens in new tab). “Finding out how common these are, and what they look like is a crucial step towards this.”
The research (opens in new tab) will be presented on July 12 at the National Astronomy Meeting (NAM 2022).